
Performance Management & Discipline
Workplace Culture and Employee Retention
July 19, 2024
5 reactions to have when an employee gets emotional during a contribution appreciation meeting?
Contribution appraisal meetings are key moments for assessing performance, offering constructive feedback and motivating employees. However, these meetings can sometimes be emotionally charged. When an employee becomes emotional during these meetings, it’s crucial for professionals to react appropriately to maintain a respectful and productive environment. Here are some strategies for dealing effectively with these situations.
1. Remain calm and understanding
When emotions arise, the first rule is to remain calm and understanding. Emotions are a natural part of the human experience and can be triggered by a variety of factors, including stress, unmet expectations or personal problems. Adopting a calm, empathetic attitude helps defuse the situation and shows the employee that you take their feelings seriously.
2. Give space, if needed
Sometimes, an employee may need a few minutes to calm down before continuing the discussion. Offering this opportunity can be very beneficial. You could, for example, offer a short break and ensure that the employee feels supported, not abandoned, throughout the meeting.
3. Active listening
Active listening is essential to understanding the employee’s concerns and showing that you value his or her point of view. This involves focusing fully on what the employee is saying, without interrupting or judging. You can do this by making eye contact and nodding your head to show that you’re following. In addition, you can rephrase what the employee has shared with you and ask open-ended questions to encourage them to express themselves further.
4. Offer solutions and support
Once the employee has expressed his emotions and you understand his concerns, work together to find solutions. Offering support and appropriate resources shows that you are invested in his or her well-being. Discuss options for dealing with the issue raised. Set clear, realistic goals for the future, making sure the employee feels involved in the process.
5. Follow-up after the meeting
Follow-up is crucial to show the employee that his or her concerns have not been forgotten. Proper follow-up builds trust and demonstrates an ongoing commitment to the employee’s development and well-being. Schedule a follow-up meeting to discuss progress and any necessary adjustments. Send a supportive message or e-mail, reminding you of the points discussed and the steps to be taken. Continue to offer constructive feedback and regular support.
Conclusion
Contribution appreciation meetings can sometimes provoke emotional reactions. As a professional, knowing how to react calmly, empathetically and effectively is crucial to maintaining a positive and productive working environment. By remaining understanding, actively listening and offering ongoing support, you can help your employees navigate through their emotions and emerge strengthened and motivated.

Jessica Dufresne, CPHR
Human Resources Consultant
Plan a connection callAdvice Centre
Discover more inspiring content
Find out how our methodology has transformed companies from different sectors. Each article is proof of our expertise.

Employee Coaching & Training, Workplace Culture and Employee Retention
Fulfillment at Work: Breaking Taboos to Cultivate Well-Being in the workplace

Overall Compensation & Pay Equity
Back to Salary transparency: boosting employee well-being
The benefits of pay transparency: employee motivation, commitment and well-being.

Performance Management & Discipline, Strategy & Organizational Performance
Pomeroy Lodging: Effective Methods for Navigating the Complex Waters of Organizational Transformation
Discover the RACI method and the 9 Box Grid: a case study in the successful organizational transformation of Pomeroy Lodging.

News & Editorials
An HR consultant posture: consultation VS the advisory role
Discover the importance of the human resources consultant's posture. Optimize your exchanges and promote the implementation of best HR practices.

Workplace Culture and Employee Retention
Revolutionizing onboarding, with or without new technologies
Discover the latest trends in HR integration and onboarding. Experience Iceberg Management to help you achieve your ambitions.

Employee Coaching & Training
Managers in Bloom: The Power of Management Coaching
Discover the lasting benefits of management coaching. Autonomy, responsibility and commitment for high-performance, harmonious teams.

News & Editorials
4 reasons to use HR outsourcing?
Discover how HR outsourcing can be an essential strategy for meeting the complex challenges of human capital management. A solution that offers much more than the simple delegation of tasks, and represents a decision-making aid for companies of all sizes! With HR Outsourcing, you can free up valuable time and resources.

Employee Coaching & Training
Optimize your team’s performance with AtmanCo psychometric tests
Use Atmanco's psychometric tests to strengthen the cohesion and efficiency of your teams and stimulate their growth and development.

Strategy & Organizational Performance
When mom has to work: juggling personal and professional life with a flexible work culture.

News & Editorials
Wise reminder: good holiday party practices

News & Editorials
3 things I’ve learned from the Grand Rendez-Vous RH Manufacturier, illuminating the path to excellence.

Recruitment & Employer Brand
What about IA for staffing
"Workshop with Sandrine Théard focused on how AI can transform recruitment by capitalizing on non-value-added tasks to save time and improve efficiency."